Just Read: #UnderTheTuscanSun By Frances Mayes (20th Anniversary Edition)

Under The Tuscan Sun Book Review On Novels And Nonfiction

When I looked into choosing Under The Tuscan Sun as my next Blogging For Books selection, I couldn’t believe that the book was actually published in 1996 and that it is now being released in a 20th Anniversary Edition. I was a bit skeptical of whether the descriptions of Italian life would feel authentic to me, coming from a foreigner, but I immediately fell in love with Frances Mayes’ writing and points of view on Italian culture. She’s really intent on learning as much as she can about Italian traditions and on immersing herself in the authentic life of the small Italian town she lives in.

I decided to watch the movie based on the book and starring Diane Lane and Raoul Bova (if you don’t know who Raoul Bova is, do yourself a favor and Google him). It came out in 2003 and to be honest felt over-caricatured and quite dated. The book in comparison still feels fresh and applicable to the current reality of Italian life in small towns in the Tuscany countryside. Another major difference between the book and the movie is that in the movie, Diane Lane’s character is recently divorced and travels alone to Tuscany to restructure Bramasole (the old house she’s bought), and hopefully also find love. In the book, on the other hand, Frances Mayes is actually remarried and restructures Bramasole with the help of her new husband Ed. I just wanted to specify for people who loved or hated the movie, that the memoir has a completely different feel and even a different storyline. It stands apart from the movie and is worth a read for its own merits.

Under The Tuscan Sun Book Review On Novels And NonfictionUnder The Tuscan Sun

by Frances Mayes

Published: September 1, 1996


Plot Teaser (from Goodreads)

Frances Mayes—widely published poet, gourmet cook, and travel writer—opens the door to a wondrous new world when she buys and restores an abandoned villa in the spectacular Tuscan countryside. In evocative language, she brings the reader along as she discovers the beauty and simplicity of life in Italy. Mayes also creates dozens of delicious seasonal recipes from her traditional kitchen and simple garden, all of which she includes in the book. Doing for Tuscany what M.F.K. Fisher and Peter Mayle did for Provence, Mayes writes about the tastes and pleasures of a foreign country with gusto and passion.

What I Liked

The writing. I didn’t know that Frances Mayes was a poet but it’s a reality that rings through in every line of Under The Tuscan Sun. Her writing is lyrical, sensuous and tactile – the reader really feels like he or she is standing alongside Mayes on the terrace of her house early in the morning, reading a book and sipping an Espresso, or walking with Mayes along the garden terraces surrounding Bramasole. Having just left Italy a few weeks before starting to read Under The Tuscan Sun, I really felt that Mayes brought my country and the people in that region of Tuscany to life in a very authentic and vivid way. The structure of the book, written as a series of essays or journal entries, and Mayes’ origins as a poet reminded me of May Sarton’s journals in which she also beautifully reflects on the details of everyday life. Among May Sarton’s journals I would above all recommend The House By The Sea. Sarton’s writing is quieter than Mayes and there’s less activity to it, but their tone and writing style are similar.

The food descriptions and recipes. As any good Italian, I’m a lover of all food and of the art of cooking itself. So much of Mayes’ writing in Under The Tuscan Sun is focused on her excursions to Cortona to buy sublimely in season ingredients at its open air markets, then returning to Bramasole to turn them into simple but delicious sounding roasts, desserts and salads. I really appreciated that Mayes included the recipes for many of the dishes she described at the end of two of the chapters in her memoir. Two that I’ll definitely have to try are Risotto With Red Chard and Bruschette With Pecorino And Prosciutto. In fact, Mayes shares my love of putting just about anything on toasted bread – a woman to my own heart. I also really liked that Mayes brought the focus back to the taste and origin of the food she prepares and eats in her memoir. I think part of U.S. culture is an obsession with counting calories and dieting, and we’re all a bit more focused on our nutrition or weight-loss goals since it’s the beginning of a new year. It was nice to be reminded that food is a pleasure and should be treated first and foremost as such, and as long as you live an active lifestyle and are eating fresh ingredients, the calories will take care of themselves.

The storyline of the restoration of Bramasole. In addition to being a toast addict, I’m a bit of an HGTV addict as well, in part influenced by the fact that my father owns a construction company in Italy. I really enjoyed reading Mayes’ descriptions of her dealings with different construction managers and crews and her difficulty in trying to keep them to their original time schedules. I have to say my father’s construction company in Milan does operate on time, but it’s not abnormal for Italian construction workers to promise unrealistic completion schedules only to have to significantly extend them. I also really loved the details about Mayes and her husband’s work in restoring Bramasole’s gardens. I’m interested in urban gardening and subsistence farming, so I found the details of how they brought their olive trees back to life and were finally able to have the olive pressed into Bramasole’s own olive oil absolutely fascinating.

What I Didn’t Like

Occasionally repetitive. Due to the memoir’s format as a collection of essays or journal entries, occasionally Mayes covered the same topic twice, whether it was a recipe, a story about a particular character in the town or an event she participated in. These repetitions marred the flow of the story, and in fact the memoir’s structure as separate essays also made the chapters feel a bit disconnected.

Final Verdict

5 Rabbits Rating On Novels And Nonfiction

Sensuous, delicious, nearly edible memoir of a foreigner’s efforts to authentically fit in to life in the small Tuscan town of Cortona and to bring back a beautiful Italian villa to its former splendor.

Have you read Under The Tuscan Sun or any of Frances Mayes other books? What did you think of them? Let me know in the comments.

If you’d like to keep up to date with posts on Novels And Nonfiction, make sure to follow me on WordPress, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram or Pinterest.

You can also read other recent reviews on the blog including for astronomy related titles Hidden Figures by Margot Shetterly and The Glass Universe by Dava Sobel, medical memoir Working Stiff by Judy Melinek MD and T.J. Mitchell, or thriller The Twilight Wife by A.J. Banner.

Please note this post contains affiliate links from Book Depository. I received a review copy of Under The Tuscan Sun’s 20th Anniversary edition from Blogging For Books in exchange for an honest review.

  21 comments for “Just Read: #UnderTheTuscanSun By Frances Mayes (20th Anniversary Edition)

  1. January 17, 2017 at 6:00 pm

    This is one of my grandmother’s favorite novels, and no wonder why – the food! I’ve never read it because I’ve seen the movie, so I’m glad to hear it’s so different. Thanks for the review!

    Liked by 1 person

    • January 17, 2017 at 8:20 pm

      Hey Julia! It’s a memoir which is even better. The memoir is way more realistic and relatable than the movie. Check it out if you have time! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. January 17, 2017 at 7:26 pm

    This review makes me so happy. I love all your personal connections back to your home country. This really reinforces that Mayes accurately portrays things, which is important in my reading! I haven’t read Under the Tuscan Sun before. I had heard the movie was lack-luster and that had turned me off from the book. BUT. I love food (things on toast?! I had smoked salmon, cream cheese, and capers on toast for lunch today) and any sort of epistolary or essay formatted book. Bring it on.
    (P.S. Thanks for doing the Googling for us! 🙂 )


    • January 17, 2017 at 8:20 pm

      That toast sounds delicious – I like to do cream cheese and smoked salmon on a bagel with lemon juice, salt and pepper. Yes, I think whether you liked or didn’t like the movie has little to no bearing on liking the book, since they are very different. Definitely the saving grace of the movie was Raoul Bova for me 😉 lol

      Liked by 1 person

  3. January 17, 2017 at 9:53 pm

    A friend recommended this book to me a long time ago, and I finally found it in a thrift shop for $1. I haven’t read it yet, but your review is reminding me of the yummy food-y goodness to be found in the pages (and the reason my friend thought I would like it!).

    Liked by 1 person

    • January 17, 2017 at 10:20 pm

      Yes! That’s a great deal 🙂 I hope you do end up liking it – I think Spring would be a good time to read it because the narrative spans various seasons, so it would be good to be in a moment of transition between Winter and Summer.

      Liked by 1 person

      • January 18, 2017 at 2:02 am

        Thanks for the tip!


  4. BJ
    January 24, 2017 at 6:58 pm

    If I didn’t know the movie was made from the book, I would never have guessed. The book was so much better. The movie was fun, but so different from the book. Mainly, they shared a title and many of the same characters, but that is about it. I have read this book about 3 times and loved it every time. I have also read the second one, the title escapes me right now and it was good, but not as good as the first. The third one in the series, I have on my TBR shelf.

    Liked by 1 person

    • January 24, 2017 at 9:56 pm

      I didn’t actually know that there were follow-up memoirs but I looked them up and they’re called Every Day in Tuscany and Bella Tuscany. You seem ambivalent about the immediate sequel to Under The Tuscan Sun- would you recommend that I check it out?


      • BJ
        January 24, 2017 at 10:05 pm

        I think her writing is beautiful, I just didn’t enjoy it as much as the first one, which is very often typical of sequels. It’s just more of their time in Tuscany, places that they went, food that they ate (her descriptions are wonderful!). It was good, just not as good. Where I have re-read the first, I have not re-read the second and probably will not and It didn’t make me anxious to read the third one.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. January 25, 2017 at 4:01 am

    It’s been awhile since I’ve read this, but I remember enjoying the same things you highlighted. Her descriptive writing just made me feel like I was right there with her!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: